Product & Startup Builder

Concerning trends in thinking

Added on by Chris Saad.

I share the following not to call out the individual I spoke to but rather to draw out broader themes that concern me from a single case study…


I recently had a discussion with a young person who told me about the concept of the “Resource Based Economy” from something called "The Venus Project."

The conversation occurred because he had messaged me, claiming that he had a big idea that he wanted to talk to me about.

He was rightly very distressed about the state of the world. War, hunger, corruption, etc.

Aren’t we all?

He pointed me to the Venus Project video attached below.

According to him, it would be an awesome idea for all of humanity to collectively decide to contribute their resources to a global commons and then have some kind of artificial intelligence allocate those resources as it sees fit. He also advocated for the end of money and politics.

Confused, I asked him, “OK, assuming all of this is true and desirable, what is your idea for a product, service, institution, project, or action that might move us toward this goal?”

His answer “well, I think we first need to change the global operating system and switch to this resource-based economy.”

Here are my concerns with all of the above.

Many people - particularly young people - don’t seem to understand…

1. How to affect change in their environment

His plan to change the world was “Step 1: change the world”. When pressed for an actionable initiative, he seemed very confused.

2. The dangers and history of the old “isms”

It seems to me that very old and very bad ideas are in vogue right now. They just go by new, more palatable names.

The individual I was speaking to even argued that we just need new names and narratives to sell his ideas to everyone.

Concepts like “The Venus Project, “The Resource Based Economy,” and even “Trumpism” or “MAGA” are simply rebranded Socialism or Facism respectively.

Even woke-ism has become - for many - a way to silence or control speech.

Young people are looking at failing democratic processes, and some are wondering why we don’t act in a more unified way, like China.

They don’t understand it’s the institutions that need to be fixed and that democracy is the worst form of government, except for all the others.

They don’t understand that a failure to provide good social programs within a capitalist system is the issue - rather than the fanciful and dangerous idea of abolishing capitalism itself.

They don’t understand that well-regulated global capitalism incentivizes the creation of ever-improving products and services at a scale and scope never before seen in human history.

Also, having resource allocation by AI? Have people not seen iRobot and Westworld?

3. The purpose and value of money as a medium for exchanging value

It’s been a common prevailing feeling that money is the root of all evil.

Money is simply a means to store and transfer value.

I have thoroughly explored ideas of reputation, economies, attention economies, and trading economies. They simply don’t work.

Money enables capitalism and civilization to occur.

Abolishing money would send us back to the stone age.

4. The purpose and value of politics

Differences of opinion and conflict between humans are inevitable.

It is difficult enough to understand oneself and maintain alignment with one’s partner, much less maintain agreement with your neighbor or "tribes" in other lands.

Prior to good functioning political systems and foreign diplomacy, we used to kill neighbors and go to war at the drop of a hat.

Politics is war without guns and bullets.

It allows the debate of ideas and minimizes – to the degree possible - control by a physically powerful minority.

5. Quality content and thinking vs. nonsense

The video below is silly. And yet it captures people's attention. People of all ages and intellects, it seems.

Why?

When there's so much high-quality, deep thinking, it's concerning that many of us can't tell a scam from the truth, true insight from cynicism or magical thinking.

With AI deep-fakes coming fast on the horizon, we are doomed if we can't find a way to educate people to discern fact from fiction. Ground truth from nonsense.

6. Overall, the world is fundamentally getting better all the time.

All the signals of global social cohesion and peace are trending in the right direction.

Of course, there are bumps along the road, but generally speaking, we are in a multi-decade, broad-based slope of improvement.

Very few people seem to know this.

7. I feel old.

Ukraine is Palestine, 60 years ago.

Added on by Chris Saad.

Ukraine is Palestine, 60 years ago.

I’m really glad that the world has come together with moral clarity to defend Ukraine and condemn Russia. Most of the people on the planet have correctly recognized that this is about standing up for justice and freedom.

It’s beautiful and righteous and powerful.

I wonder though. What would happen if…

  1. Russia was to occupy Ukraine and essentially turn it into an open-air prison for 50 or 60 years.

  2. The Ukrainians become increasingly desperate and are forced to resort to asymmetric warfare (roadside bombs, homemade rockets).

  3. Every now and then the Ukrainians mount desperate attempts to make some kind of dent against their military oppressors with surges of violence.

  4. Russia massively overreacts to any resistance by bombing huge swaths of Ukrain back to the Stone Age.

Would we all have the same moral clarity?

Would we call Ukrainians “freedom fighters” or “terrorists”? Would we have endless debates on Facebook about who started it?

Maybe some would argue that Ukraine was Russia’s spiritual homeland and they deserve to be there.

Maybe some would argue that the Ukrainians are terrorists and don’t deserve our sympathy.

Maybe some would argue that the Ukrainians should find a more peaceful way to get what they want.

Maybe some would call for normalizing relations with Russia.

Maybe Russia might develop clever narratives that make any criticism of their military policies an act of bigotry.

Maybe our moral clarity will turn to confusion, uncertainty, exhaustion, and silence.

In short, maybe, just maybe, it might look more like the Palestinian and Israeli “conflict”.

Star Trek is the opposite of Star Wars

Added on by Chris Saad.

People love to compare, compete or lump Star Trek and Star Wars together.

It's self-evident that they are totally different from each other.

It struck me this morning, however, how they are actually the polar opposite of each other.

Some examples…

Star Wars is about humans defeating technology using intuition and spirituality. Star Trek is about technology defeating scarcity so that humans can be logical and rational.

Star Wars is about fiercely individual people who reluctantly and temporarily cooperate when their interests align relying on raw talent and luck. Star Trek is about people who pledge loyalty to each other and go through extensive training to work in concert to overcome their obstacles.

Star Wars is about the needs of the individuals (our heroes) outweighing the needs of the many (the empire) - an anti-fascism message. Star Trek is about the tension and balance between the needs of the many and the needs of the one - a message of individual rights and contributions within effective institutions for collective action.

Star Wars is about war. Star Trek is about peace.

Star Wars is about solving problems with weapons. Star Trek is about solving problems with words.

Star Wars is about scientifically impossible things. Star Trek is about scientifically inevitable things.

Star Wars is about scarcity. Star Trek is about abundance.

I like Star Wars. It's fun. But I live Star Trek.

Yes, I'm proudly a nerd who over-thinks this stuff.

What are you afraid of?

Added on by Chris Saad.

What are you afraid of?

Write it down.

Now write down the next bad thing that happens after that. And then what happens after that?

Now write down probabilities of each thing happening on each line.

Now write down the combined probabilities of each thing happening next to that.

Essentially this is a failure funnel.

Now ask which level of failure do you think is likely to occur. Can you live with that outcome?

The answer might surprise you.

Here’s an example for someone afraid to change jobs. The numbers are a stab in the dark. Each person’s guess will be different.

The first number is the likelyhood of that event occurring. The second number is the combined likelyhood of all the things above occurring together.

Changing jobs:

- Failing at ALL the interviews you have (50%)

- Failing to enjoy the new job (20%, 10%)

- Failing to succeed at the new job (20%, 2%)

- Get fired (20%, 0.4%)

- Failing to find another job (20%, 0.08%

- Failing to feed your family (20%, 0.016%)

Now let’s do it in reverse. What about the best case scenarios?

- Get a few job offers (80%)

- Get a better salary offer than the salary you have (80%, 64%)

- Use the better offer to negotiate a better salary from your current job or take the new job (your choice - you don’t even need to do this!) (80%, 51.2%)

- Be happier at your new job (80%, 40.96%)

So 0.016% chance of failing to feed your family and 40.96% of improving your job satisfaction and salary.

Life is about optimizing probabilities.

What are you afraid of?

Silicon Valley vs Australia

Added on by Chris Saad.

I miss Silicon Valley. I love Australia.

They are both awesome. Here are some examples.

Disclaimer: these are my own personal feelings and massive generalizations. They’re also colored by my perspectives and the stage of life I was at in each place. There are variations and exceptions to every rule.

Infinite possibilities vs Safety

In Silicon Valley, it feels like anything is possible. At any moment you could meet someone life-changing, fund something game-changing, have an idea that is revelatory.

In Australia, it feels like everything is safe. You don’t realize how much cognitive load is lifted when you don’t have to worry about banks and insurance companies taking advantage of you, people shooting children in their schools, or retailers selling you toxic things.

Curiosity vs Contentment

In Silicon Valley, everyone is curious about everything. So many discussions are about big ideas and deep explorations. People unpack topics and then unpack them even further - trying to burrow right down into the truth of things. Everything has room for improvement or outright reinvention.

In Australia, everyone is so content with where they are and what’s going on. There’s no need to over-think or ruminate. Just enjoy the scenery and life. You can spend life living instead of dissecting and reinventing. Take a breath. Enjoy!

Speed vs Smelling the roses

In Silicon Valley, everything moves so fast. The actual road speed limit is mostly just a suggestion. Everyone is speeding a little and as long as everyone is speeding the same amount the cops don’t really bother you. You can achieve more in a week than most people achieve in a month. It’s thrilling. It feels like your life can make an outsized impact on the world.

In Australia, everyone is driving under the speed limit. If you’re going 67kph in a 60 zone the automated speed cameras will send you a fine in the mail. Why? Because what’s the rush? Life is good. You get to relax, smell the roses, enjoy the sun, drink a beer, play some sport. Take it easy.

Changing the world vs Living in it

Everyone you meet in Silicon Valley is changing the world in some way. They work on products that affect the lives of millions or billions - if not right now, then maybe one day In the near future. These people are often also passionate about reinventing or pushing forward issues of relationships, race, governance, and other fundamental aspects of society. They’re making a dent in the universe. Nothing is decided.

Most people you meet in Australia are living *in* the world. They are digging stuff out of the ground or selling patches of dirt or fixing plumbing or serving drinks or selling stuff in a store. They are “real” people living with their feet firmly planted in the ground. No silly flights of fancy disconnected from reality. No constant splitting of hairs about the meaning of words or genders or relationships. Everything is pretty simple and straightforward.

Found family vs Actual family

In Silicon Valley, you’re able to piece together your own found family. Incredible people who share your perspectives and priorities. They become like brothers and sisters on your journey to discover and change the world.

My real family is in Australia. Flesh and blood that will always be there for me long after the buzz and hype dies off. They are the people my children must know and grow up with.

Conclusion There are pros and cons to both places.

My life must involve being part of both. I can’t wait for the borders to open up.

Black Widow review

Added on by Chris Saad.

These marvel movies and TV shows are so much better than they need to be.

They are so lovingly made and rewarding to watch.

Just finished watching Black Widow. There’s just too much for me to say in a FB post. The themes and execution are so tight.

Family, sisterhood, fatherhood, male abuse of women, women brain washed to fight each other instead of the men who victimize them, personal narratives… and so much more.

Just wow.

More broadly…

MCU Phase 1: Construct it

MCU Phase 2: Test it

MCU Phase 3: Break it

MCU Phase 4: Deconstruct it

Wandavision, Loki, Black Widow… these are beautiful, intimate character studies that dive so deeply into these wonderful, flawed characters.

These are just supposed to be silly comic book movies.

That’s just my opinion

Added on by Chris Saad.

“I am who I am.”

“Well that’s just my opinion”

Life is a series of opportunities to experience, grow, learn and achieve whatever goals you set for yourself.

If you’re not experiencing, growing, learning or achieving what you want, then a willfully stubborn attachment (or worse, a defeatist surrender) to a static set of behaviors and opinions isn’t brave, confident or effective.

Pay attention, learn, adapt, grow, improve and use your strengths to capture the opportunities you desire.

It’s often no harder than making a choice and adjusting a narrative.

As I age, I think my new narrative has to be about health.

What changes are you going to make starting today?

My smart house automations

Added on by Chris Saad.

Some #GardenSanctuary smart home features

Me: “Hey google, goodnight”

Google...

1. Front gate and garage are closed

2. Roomba vacuume is sent back to its dock

3. All garden and internal lighting turns red and dim to 20% brightness

4. Bedroom lights are turned off

5. First few meetings of the next day’s schedule are read out

6. Wake up alarm is set

7. “House secured and configured. Good night Chris”

Me: “Hey google, good morning”

Google...

1. Front gate is opened

2. Roomba vacuums the floor 3 days a week

3. All garden and internal accent lights turn bright white

4. Weather is read out

5. First few meetings of the day’s schedule are read out

6. “Good morning, Chris. House configured for a lovely day”

Me: “Hey google, play some music”

Music plays through the house - indoor and out - setting the mood and making everything sound epic.

Automatically at sunset...

All garden and internal accent lights change to lavender.

I love ❤️ technology.

Boundaries vs triggers

Added on by Chris Saad.

Boundaries are very important in life. You must understand, clarify and communicate them to others. Boundaries protect you.

However when ones boundaries are crossed the result should be a clear and rational response.

When “boundaries” create visceral emotional responses they are more aptly described as “triggers”.

Triggers are unhealthy. They are raw nerves. They don’t protect you - they hurt you and others.

Triggers require intentional work in order to dull their control over you and their distructive effects on others. The first step is to identify them explicitly. The next is to let go of the narratives that feed them. It takes time and effort.

In the mean time, try to catch yourself early during an emotional reaction and try your best to eject out as quickly as possible. Making excuses to justify your sensitivities just serves to prolong the process.

#personalperspective

Thoughts on Pixar’s movie “Soul”

Added on by Chris Saad.

Spoilers about the themes of Pixar’s “Soul” to follow...

Most movies of this kind are about “finding your purpose”.

In fact, the first 3/4ths of the movie leads you to believe that’s what it’s about.

The beautiful twist is that “Soul” is actually about living in the moment and savoring life’s simple pleasures. It’s about paying attention and having gratitude.

It even pushes back against the common tendency of admiring highly functional and “successful” people who have their “purpose”.

It really struck a cord with me. As I continue to transition from hustle focused young entrepreneur to family focused middle aged husband and (hopefully one day) father - the little moments are the moments that really matter.

It made me tear up at the end.

I guess this movie also perfectly encapsulates the thing I need to continue to work on in 2021.

Highly recommended.

The themes of Pixar’s Soul

Added on by Chris Saad.

Spoilers about the themes of Pixar’s “Soul” to follow...

Most movies of this kind are about “finding your purpose”.

In fact the first 3/4ths of the movie leads you to believe that’s what it’s about.

The beautiful twist is that “Soul” is actually about living in the moment and savoring life’s simple pleasures. It’s about paying attention and having gratitude.

It even pushes back against the common tendency of admiring highly functional and “successful” people who have their “purpose”.

It really struck a cord with me. As I continue to transition from hustle focused young entrepreneur to family focused middle aged husband and (hopefully one day father) - the little moments are the moments that really matter.

Remember your agency and check your narratives

Added on by Chris Saad.

Regular reminder:

1. You are the only one you can control. Taking maximum accountability for your choices and experiences makes you are an empowered creator of your life instead of a victim.

If someone is hurting you and you do not distance yourself - you are the one to blame. Not them.

2. Your narratives play a big role in the decisions you ultimately make. Being vigilant about pruning or rewriting false narratives or narratives that no longer serve you allows you to write a new, better story.

If you tell yourself comforting lies then you will make ill-informed decisions that undermine your happiness and success.

3. You and your decisions are not immutable. New information will produce new decisions. You get to change your narratives and choices every second of every day.

Who do you want to be tomorrow? Decide on the ideal and work backward from there.

Democrats need to reframe the debate

Added on by Chris Saad.

If I was part of the new Biden administration, the first thing I’d do is release a glossary of terms and policies we believe in - specifically designed to reframe the debate.

I’d tell the extreme left that “We can not make major strides forward if we're arguing amongst ourselves about each issue. Our strategy will be to peruse the art of the possible. Get on board and let’s move the ball down the field. We’re going to start by choosing more inclusive phrases that everyone can get behind.”

I'd tell the extreme right that "Most of what you've heard from your friends and conservative media is a lie. We are not socialists. We are not the enemy. We do not have a secret plan to take away your guns or your healthcare. Listen carefully to our actual words and watch the results of our actions and you will find the truth - the rest is just propaganda designed to make you afraid of real and essential progress."

I’d say...

Instead of “defund the police”, we’re going to “help the police”. Specifically, we’re going to invest more in social services, mental health services, and work with departments to teach de-escalation. Our police deserve to have an entire army of supporting services to help them protect and support our communities.

Instead of “black lives matter” we’re going to say “black lives deserve justice too”. Specifically, we're going to work to ensure our laws and our systems compensate for historical and ongoing injustices that hold back our friends and neighbors from having equal access to liberty and freedom.

Instead of talking about “socialism” we’re going to talk about “progressive values”. Specifically, we’re going to develop a new, gentler capitalism that has clear rules that balance the needs of labor with the needs of corporations and shareholders.

Instead of talking about “big government” vs “small government” we’re going to talk about "smart government" that effectively does what government must do. Protect the nation and protect the most vulnerable from suffering and violence.

Instead of talking about a “minimum wage”, we’re going to talk about “living wage”. Because no one deserves to be a modern-day slave. If you work a full-time job, you should be able to pay your rent and put food on the table.

Instead of talking about “more taxes” and “lower taxes” we’re going to talk about making sure that taxes are fairer and easier to understand and pay.

Instead of talking about “healthcare” and “Obamacare” we’re going to talk about “the right to life”. We believe that people deserve to live without going bankrupt or dying because of profit-hungry insurance companies.

Instead of “left” vs “right”, we’re going to talk about moving "forward" together.

None of this is particularly hard. Many advanced countries have done it before us. But in the last couple of decades, we have been so hell-bent on fighting each-other and fearing our government that we have fallen behind on the essential work of keeping our citizens safe, educated, and healthy. We must work together to catch up and keep up with the rest of the developed world or risk losing the American dream forever.

----

That’s how hearts and minds are won. Through language and reframing the argument.

Democrats suck at this. They must get better.

Biden wins! But it's not over.

Added on by Chris Saad.

9/11 was a day of terror the world will never forget. In many ways, Trump’s presidency was (and will likely continue to be for quite some time) a sustained terrorizing of the American and global population for 4 years.

Every day, every tweet, every executive order was a horrifying display of leadership without empathy, courage or concern for the people. Many seemed designed as a tool of psychological warfare. It was a case study for how a system that relied on norms and basic human decency could be abused and contorted to serve the whims of bigotry, selfishness and fear.

Biden is like a healing balm that might take the temperature down. But he is not a cure.

America still suffers from the illness of coronavirus. It still has an electoral college and districting system that suppresses the vote. It’s still filled with undereducated and underpaid people who’s education and social system has failed them - making them sick, desperate and scared. It is still lead - in large part - by disgusting craven men who have no shame, courage or empathy.

This is to say nothing of what Trump and his cult will do next.

I am relieved that Donald is experiencing some nominal consequences for his character and actions over the last four years. But this is not over. Not by a long shot.

Remember your agency. I have not just been "Lucky".

Added on by Chris Saad.

“You won the lottery”. “You’re lucky”. “It’s easy for you.”

These are the some of the phrases that I hear a lot from well-meaning friends and acquaintances. They’re all different ways of saying the same thing. That to them, the aspects of my life that they can see from social media and occasional parties are the result of good fortune.

I thought instead of sharing some good news or political opinions today, I’d, instead, take the time to share some of the hard or intentional things I’ve had to do to get where I am.

I absolutely do not do this for anyone to feel sorry for me or to suggest that my life is harder than someone else’s. I know that I have some incredible baseline privilege in my life. To name just a few: Being a straight man born to great parents in a middle class family, in a relatively safe neighborhood, in a safe and generous country, with relatively few outwardly disabling genetic illnesses.

But I have also faced (and still continue to face) hard decisions and challenges. I want to share just a few of these because it might inspire people to recognize their own agency in the face of adversity.

1. Health: Depending on many factors that change over the course of my life, I have either mild or acute social anxiety that flares on a weekly or even daily basis. This will often result in anything from slight shortness of breath all the way to full-blown panic attacks that make me want to throw up. This has been a significant factor in pretty much all of my movements throughout my life. From simply going to the shopping center all the way to jumping on a plane to go to Silicon Valley or taking on new jobs, having important meetings with clients and of course public speaking. It makes literally everything harder and, I believe, has been a major limiting factor in my career and contentment. Things that might otherwise be happy occasions - like my wedding - were things to dread and situations to manage so that my own mental health wouldn’t get in the way of my happiness and the happiness of my partner and friends.

2. Relationship: Aliya and I have an amazing relationship and we intentionally “love out loud”. That means we are affectionate in public and often post about each other on social media. But any relationship is not easy to create nor is it easy to maintain. For example I was born and raised in Australia and she was born and raised in Pakistan. The result is big cultural differences involving religion, world views and popular culture. These were not just things we had to overcome between each other, but they were also something that deeply concerned her family. We (especially Aliya) had to work very hard to put her family at ease about our relationship before taking it to the next level - right up to and including our wedding day. The differences between us and the concerns from her family were not trivial. We have each had to make incredibly intentional and hard compromises and evolutions to be in each others life. This barely scratches the surface of what it takes to make our amazing relationship work. But we DK all of this because we love each other and we know we are right for each other. We do it because we know anything worthwhile takes intentional effort. Our partnership is not luck. It is a choice that we make every day.

3. Work: While my work and my situation right now is profitable, this is only a recent development. It is the result of constant grinding over 20+ years. I have launched and built countless projects and companies. Each of them has failed to live up to my hopes and expectations in their own way. Up until recently, all of my work has really resulted in very little monetary success. It’s required resilience, grit, consistency, curiosity, optimism, risk-taking, and an enormous force of will (particularly in the face of my anxiety) to keep moving forward and get to where I am. It is exactly this difficult journey that makes it possible for me to relate to - and add value to - the journey of founders and startups today.

This is by no means an exhaustive list. Nor does it go into every difficult detail. Not even close. But I hope these few examples can serve as inspiration to others who feel like they have hard things to deal with or that others people have it easy.

Finally I’d like to say that I am available for anyone who is reading this. If you were going through a tough time and need someone to talk to, I am here!

How I think

Added on by Chris Saad.

I was just thinking about how I think today. Meta!

The following description and diagram came to mind:

I try to always make "ideal" decisions and actions.

What is ideal? For me, it is a decision or action that is at the intersection of Love & Optimism, Maximum Justice, Kindness and generosity, Effectiveness, Effectiveness, My Intentions & goals, Exceptionalism, Personal gratification.

Each of those must be grounded in the "Objective Truth". That is a roughly right model of the world that is as free of bias and dogma as possible. Typically determined by curiosity, perspective, intuition, and introspection.

Frame 2 (4).png

“I’m a daughter”

Added on by Chris Saad.

“I’m a daughter”

My wife Aliya came home and told me that the staff at Bunnings (think “costco for home improvement” for my non-Australian friends) are wearing this kind of label on their uniforms now.

We both knew immediately what it meant. When she told me it instantly broke my heart. Aliya confirmed our hypothesis with the staff member.

Service staff are being harassed and abused by customers. This label is intended to remind potential abusers of their humanity.

You really can’t argue someone into a broader and more generous sense of empathy.

They either have it or they don’t.

Maybe you can help someone get a fuller sense of the context and facts of someone else’s life. Maybe even you can remind them, in a heated moment, of their existing empathetic instincts. But it seems to me, some people lack the basic ability to imagine themselves in someone else’s shoes.

The former might be helpful when dealing with complex issues like systemic racism and poverty. It might even be useful when dealing with a detached voice over the phone that is only providing scripted responses. But for people to require a reminder of someone’s basic humanity when they are right in front of them, in a store, face-to-face? It’s beyond me.

I can’t believe it needs to be said over and over, but here it is again. A snippet from the section on Empathy from my upcoming book:

“One of the ways to improve your empathy is to remember that everyone is suffering. Each of us wears different masks in different contexts. A work mask, a friendship mask, a family mask, and so on.

Either through conscious effort or through a simple limitation of our facial expressions and communication skills, those masks often reveal only a small fraction of the emotional journey going on inside us. It is even more rare that we can fully express the depths of our childhood traumas or the personal challenges we’re going through. This is especially so at work.

Despite knowing this about ourselves, we often accept whatever we are presented (a polished or dialed down version), forgetting about the suffering of the people with whom we are interacting each day.

Leaders try to remember that the inner emotional journey of others is likely as rich, complex, and difficult as their own. It is a journey they might not even fully understand, or one of which they may not be completely conscious. They recognize that maintaining a healthy relationship with anyone must start with internalizing this fact. Doing so often means that any generous interpretation of (and reaction to) others’ actions includes empathy and patience for their suffering, their perspective, and their fears. Leaders also know that they might sometimes need to play a role in alleviating the suffering of the people they encounter.”

In short: try to be kinder please.

Understanding Black Lives Matter if you've never lived in the US.

Added on by Chris Saad.

A number of my Australian and other non-US friends are struggling to understand “Black Lives Matter”. To help them understand the situation a little. better, I wrote the following on Facebook last week.

“Black Lives Matter” has very little to do with you or your lived experience right now - so don’t feel bad if you don’t get it.

Here’s some context that might make it clearer so you can show some empathy for our American friends.

The phrase might be better and more accurately written “Black Lives Matter, Too”

It is in response to ongoing, pervasive, and often intentional, *systemic* racism in the US. Therefore this is not about individuals against individuals. It is not just about 1 or 2 police shootings. It is about institutionalized *systems* designed to oppress a specific group of people built right into the government and laws.

This has been going on since the country's founding and continues to this day. From slavery to Jim Crow, to specific laws designed to entrap and disenfranchise African Americans - they have *never* had equity in the US.

For a simple example: Right now, the US prison system is (massively) disproportionately overflowing with African Americans and other people of color. More than were ever enslaved during the era of slavery. This is not because they are naturally more prone to crime. It’s because a legacy of oppression, under and over-policing, and laws designed to make their benign behavior criminal (e.g crack cocaine penalties are harsher than powder cocaine because the former is typically taken by people of color).

The law is also applied unevenly. While an African American might get jail time for possession of a small amount of marijuana, a white youth might get let off with some community service. The resulting criminal history means that they can no longer get work or vote. The cycle repeats.

There are other, more subtle, and pernicious examples. African Americans and other people of color are discouraged or even blocked from voting due to the placement of polling places (not in their neighborhoods), the timing of voting (during their work hours where they are less likely to get time off). Voting districts are drawn to make their vote less meaningful and to ensure that conservatives win elections no matter what (a political leanings that typically makes things worse for minorities). This is known as gerrymandering.

The country’s systems are failing or failed. In particular for people of color. Worse, it’s now in a negative feedback loop. It’s difficult to see how they can pull up out of this nosedive.

Further, with COVID19, poor people have been hardest hit and least supported. All while the stock market goes up and up making the rich, richer, and widening the gap.

In this context, saying “all lives matter” is akin to the fire department saying “all houses matter” while watching yours burn down.